liveonearth (liveonearth) wrote,

  • Mood:

Idaho US Forest Service leaves the river WILD

The Idaho USFS has decided that they're not on call to go blast every nature-inserted obstacle from the rivers in their domain. In my view, this is great news. There are two major strainers in the Salmon River of Idaho, and they are going to stay there until nature (and river runners count as part of nature) takes them out. These obstacles will severely limit commercial use, as those operators would find the trouble of portaging their deluxe rigs to be more work than profit. And not many private boaters are likely to brave the hardship either. The reduction in river use will be a welcome break for the wildlife in that river corridor, which has to be stressed by the steady traffic of rafters during the spring and summer.

From: "Riverwire" <>

Last year’s logjam at Pistol Creek on the Middle Fork of the Salmon River has rematerialized and has been joined by a riverwide strainer (a log at river level) just above Pistol Creek at Lake Creek. Unlike last year, the US Forest Service says it has no plans to blast apart the logjam.

USFS officials stated that last July the logjam built up overnight while 200 rafters were upstream without knowing it was there, creating the difficulty of informing boaters. Some noncommercial boaters simply portaged the obstruction and one outfitter hired pack animals to move equipment and people around. USFS wilderness workers used dynamite to blow up the logjam within a few days.

This year’s logjam appears to consist of fewer logs but still blocks the river completely making the rapid unrunnable. Lake Creek’s drainage area, ravaged by fires in previous years and littered with dead trees, flooded and pushed the logs and a debris pile into the river overnight during a storm.

This spring the problem was repeated and compounded when athe live tree fell across the river just below Lake Creek. The Middle Fork’s channel at Lake Creek (RM 21.5*) has substantially changed with new bars and newly exposed sharp rocks adding to the problems. Higher water will change it again during the runoff period, so river runners need to carefully inspect this portion of river via trails before deciding on a strategy throughout the season. Pre-season river runners have lined Lake Creek and portaged Pistol Creek (RM 22.7*) or portaged both.

The USFS recently released a statement saying, in part, "It is the responsibility of every boater to be aware of conditions on the rivers and take appropriate precautions including being heads-up and scouting the rivers. It may mean portaging or lining your boats around hazards. The Salmon-Challis National Forest will not be clearing obstacles from the rivers to assure passage for boaters."

“Self-guided river runners could have an unprecedented wilderness experience this year” observes Jo Johnson of River Runners for Wilderness, “Since many commercial outfitters are unlikely to march their passengers and equipment around the obstacles if the USFS stands by the commitment to let wilderness be wild, just like Arizona ’s Salt River before it was blasted.”

Indian Creek at RM 25.2 is an alternate launch site where trips can enter below the problem area via plane shuttle and it is expected that at least some commercial outfitters will use this option.

On August 3, 2006 the Missoula, Montana-based national activist group Wilderness Watch sent a letter to then USFS Chief Dale Bosworth requesting a formal review of the agency's response to last year’s dynamiting incident. The Middle Fork is a designated Wild and Scenic River in the Frank Church-River of No Return Wilderness.

Wilderness Watch wrote, "The decision to blow up the logjam raises important questions about Wilderness and the Forest Service's stewardship. There is little doubt that other natural events of similar or greater magnitude will occur in designated Wilderness in the years ahead, and that managers will be confronted with these challenges many times. For that reason, the response to this event serves as an important learning opportunity for present and future managers, as well as for the general public."

Pictures of the strainer and logjam as of April 27, 2007 can be seen (scroll down the page) at:

Read USFS press release:
Tags: risk, river, wilderness

  • Post a new comment


    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded